Skip Navigation
Skip to contents

RCPHN : Research in Community and Public Health Nursing

OPEN ACCESS
SEARCH
Search

Articles

Page Path
HOME > Res Community Public Health Nurs > Volume 37(3); 2026 > Article
Original Article
Professional Role Identity of Medical Support Nurses in Tertiary Hospitals: A Qualitative Content Analysis
Suejin Kim1orcid, Jina Choo2,3orcid, Yura Shin2,3orcid, Songwhi Noh2,3orcid, Jiye Min2,3orcid, Youngsoo Chu1orcid, Mi Yu1orcid, Soonhee Yoon1orcid, Sung Reul Kim2orcid, Yura Choi1orcid, Eunyeong Park1orcid, Gyuhee Han1orcid, Eunsil Jeong1orcid, Soohyun Ryu1orcid, Gyeongeun Choi1orcid
Research in Community and Public Health Nursing 2026;37(3):246-260.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.12799/rcphn.2026.01585
Published online: September 30, 2026

1Department of Nursing, Korea University Anam Hospital, Seoul, Korea

2College of Nursing, Korea University, Seoul, Korea

3Transdisciplinary Major in Learning Health Systems, Graduate School, Korea University, Seoul, Korea

Corresponding author: Jina Choo, PhD, DrPH, RN Professor of Community Health Nursing College of Nursing, Korea University Anam-ro, Seongbuk-gu, Seoul 02841, Korea Tel: +82-2-3290-4925, E-mail: jinachoo@korea.ac.kr
• Received: January 22, 2026   • Revised: June 10, 2026   • Accepted: June 15, 2026

Copyright © 2026 Korean Academy of Community Health Nursing

This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution NoDerivs License. (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nd/4.0) which allows readers to disseminate and reuse the article, as well as share and reuse the scientific material. It does not permit the creation of derivative works without specific permission.

prev next
  • 681 Views
  • 31 Download
  • Purpose
    In South Korea, the healthcare workforce dispute between the government and medical associations in 2024 accelerated the expansion of medical support roles. Since the early 2000s, tertiary hospitals have relied on experienced nurses to perform expanded medical support and care coordination functions within physician-led services; these roles were later and formally referred to as “medical support nurses,” and national efforts are now underway to formalize this role. This study aims to identify the professional identity of medical support nurses by exploring how nurses working in tertiary hospitals perceive and construct their current roles and challenges within the context of the ongoing institutionalization of this role.
  • Methods
    Participants were 37 medical support nurses and 7 physicians in an S tertiary hospital in Seoul. Qualitative content analysis based on the approach of Graneheim and Lundman was conducted using data from six focus groups.
  • Results
    Three themes emerged: “Pride and Certainty of Being an Essential Professional,” highlighting their bridging and clinical coordination roles; “Ambiguity and Instability due to an Ungranted Professional Position,” reflecting insecurity and identity ambiguity; and “Desire and Desperation of Specialized Professional Settlement,” underscoring the need for recognition, structured education, and career pathways.
  • Conclusion
    Medical support nurses may play a vital role in continuity of care; however, they continue to face unclear legal and professional boundaries. Institutionalization—including legal definition, standards for clinical practice, standardized education, and career development—is urgently needed to strengthen the professional identity of medical support nurses and to support workforce policy development for this group.
As life expectancy increases and populations with complex health needs grow [1], the demand for skilled professionals who can deliver “medical support services” [2] has become increasingly critical [3,4]. The World Health Organization estimates that there will be a global shortage of approximately 11 million healthcare workforces by 2030 [5]. As healthcare costs continue to rise, workforce models that deliver “the same outcomes at lower costs” are gaining policy attention [6]. Advanced practice nurses and physician assistants are expanding as a strategic solution by providing medical support services and ease workforce shortages [7]. These professionals can be trained in a relatively short and intensive period and can share some of physicians' diagnostic, prescriptive, and procedural responsibilities [8,9].
While advanced practice nurse roles were established decades ago in the United States and United Kingdom [10], the system in South Korea has struggled to achieve full implementation. Despite legal recognition in 2000, its progress was stalled by a vague scope of practice and a lack of national insurance reimbursement [11]. In parallel, hospitals have partially relied on an unofficial workforce, commonly referred to as physician assistants, to compensate for physician shortages and the insufficient supply and implementation of qualified advanced practice nurses [12]. This workforce, while performing tasks similar to residents, have remained in a legal gray area without official titles or standardized education, often being hired as general registered nurses while performing specialized medical support services [12].
This longstanding structural discordance between legal frameworks and clinical demands reached a critical turning point with the 2024 medical crisis [13]. The crisis began when residents and medical students went on strike to protest medical school enrollment expansion [14]. Over 90% of residents submitted mass resignations, causing tertiary hospital emergency departments to partially close or reduce operations [13]. Ward capacity shrank, and both outpatient and inpatient services contracted, creating a substantial healthcare vacuum [14]. The existing advanced practice nurses were also insufficient to address the healthcare vacuum created by the residents' walkout. This led to rapidly increased demand for medical support workforce and tertiary hospitals have deployed registered nurses based on their own criteria and training under the title of “medical support nurses” to address gaps in healthcare service delivery. Accordingly, the government accelerated efforts to institutionalize medical support services, and the scope of practice as well as the qualifications of authorized nurses into the Nursing Act enacted in 2024 [2]. This Act establishes the scope of practice for “medical support services” in Article 14, defining them as support tasks performed under physician supervision and delegation [2]. This legislation officially defines “medical support services” and may serve as a foundational legal framework that encompasses the existing advanced practice nurse workforce [15]. Subsequently, the Ministry of Health and Welfare proposed regulations that specify 43 medical support tasks [16].
However, clear definitions and role boundaries remain in a transitional state [15], and this institutional ambiguity can destabilize professional identity. Professional identity is an ongoing process of self-perception and meaning-making—a fundamental way of being as a professional [17,18]. Professional identity may be closely linked to job satisfaction, work performance, retention, and the vocational development of the nursing profession [19,20]. Understanding professional identity is crucial, as it may provide the necessary evidence for establishing legal status, developing educational systems, and standardizing job functions. While recent research has begun to explore the job experiences of nurses in these unofficial medical support roles [21,22], the professional identity of medical support nurses—formally recognized following the 2024 medical crisis—has not been systematically addressed. As this role is now being actively institutionalized, grounding policy and workforce development in evidence from those working in this newly defined role is both timely and essential.
This study addresses this gap by exploring the shared perceptions of three distinct groups. Unlike previous studies [22], it adopted a multi-perspective approach by including the study participants of physicians. This acknowledges that medical support nurses assume a role in delivering medical support services while supporting and collaborating with physicians in clinical care. Furthermore, it distinguished between novice and experienced medical support nurses to capture different situational challenges and depths of reflection. This differentiated approach allows for a more comprehensive and balanced understanding of the medical support nurse role at this critical juncture.
The aim of this study was to identify the professional identity of medical support nurses through a qualitative study using focus group interviews, by exploring how nurses working in tertiary hospitals perceive and construct their current roles and challenges within the context of the ongoing institutionalization of this role. By providing foundational insights into their professional role identity, this study may contribute to the successful institutionalization and professional development of medical support nurses within the Korean healthcare system.
Study design
This is an exploratory descriptive study using focus group interviews (FGIs) to examine the professional identity of medical support nurses. FGI was chosen as it is suited for eliciting dynamic interactions that reveal shared meanings and for capturing diverse perspectives from multiple stakeholders within the same clinical context [23].
Participants
For participant recruitment, purposive sampling was employed. We obtained a list of medical support nurses from the nursing department of the affiliated hospital and contacted them. Nurses with less than six months of experience were excluded to ensure sufficient professional exposure. The study participants consisted of medical support nurses and the physicians who work alongside them. Medical support nurse participants were divided into groups based on experience level for the interviews. The novice medical support nurses included nurses who began the role during or after the 2024 medical crisis with at least six months of experience. The experienced medical support nurses consisted of nurses with over two years of experience prior to the 2024 medical crisis. The physician group comprised physicians who had collaborated with medical support nurses for a minimum of six months.
Physicians were included as a participant group for two reasons. First, for nursing professionals engaged in physician-collaborative work, role identity may be shaped not only by self-perception but also by how collaborating physicians perceive and recognize their role [24,25]. Second, including physicians allowed for direct comparison of perspectives, and the broad agreement between nurse and physician accounts strengthened the credibility of the findings. This multi-stakeholder approach complements previous qualitative work on medical support nurses [22] and enables a more balanced understanding of professional role identity.
All potential participants were contacted and invited to participate in the study. A total of 44 participants who agreed were recruited across six focus groups (Table 1): two groups of novice participants, three groups of experienced participants, and one group of physicians. From a pool of 128 eligible novice medical support nurses (i.e., novice group), 14 participants participated to form two focus groups (7 members per group). Among 84 eligible experienced medical support nurses (i.e., experienced group), 23 participants participated and allocated in three focus groups (7-9 members per group). Furthermore, one physician focus group (i.e., physician group) was formed with seven participants. There was no participant attrition throughout the process.
Focus group interviews and data collection
FGIs were conducted over 6 days between June 23 and July 4, 2025, in a conference room at affiliated hospital. We followed the methods outlined by Morgan and Krueger (1998) [26]. The six preliminary research team members, including the first author, conducted the interviews in pairs, with one serving as moderator and the other as assistant interviewer. The assistant interviewer was responsible for audio-recording and transcription. Prior to the interviews, the team held extensive discussions and established a standardized interview guideline to ensure consistency across all six interview sessions. The average interview duration was 78 minutes and 36 seconds. All interviews were audio-recorded with participants' prior consent.
A semi-structured, open-ended questionnaire was developed through a literature review on medical support nurses and advanced practice nurses. The questionnaire consisted of introductory, main, and closing questions. Before starting the FGIs, the study's purpose was explained to participants. The moderator explained the basic discussion principles to participants before starting and created an atmosphere where participants could speak freely. With participants' consent, all interviews were audio-recorded, and assistant interviewers took notes during the sessions. The recorded content was transcribed verbatim by the researchers using the Clova app, preserving participants' exact language. To capture the main flow and atmosphere of the interviews and to improve transcription accuracy, four of researchers reviewed transcripts on the day of each interview. After completing transcription, two of researchers cross-checked the recordings, transcripts, and field notes to verify accuracy. Immediately after each session, the research team conducted debriefing. No repeat interviews were conducted.
Data analysis
The transcribed interview content totaled 150 A4 pages. During analysis, we referenced recorded debriefing content and field notes. Following Graneheim and Lundman's (2004) analysis procedure [27], we repeatedly read the data to grasp the overall meaning, then marked meaningful words, sentences, and paragraphs related to the research topic to extract meaning units. Through condensation, we named these meaning units as codes while maintaining their core essence. We then compared similarities and differences in content, grouped similar codes into sub-categories, and further integrated similar sub-categories into abstract final categories. Data were collected progressively and analyzed concurrently. Data collection continued until no new themes emerged, indicating theoretical saturation.
Ethical consideration
This study was approved by the Institutional Review Board of Korea University Hospital (IRB No. K2025-0730-005). Researchers explained the purpose and process of the study, audio recording procedures, data storage and anonymity measures, and informed participants of their right to voluntarily withdraw from the study. After explaining these ethical considerations and the analysis process through FGI, we obtained written informed consent from all participants before proceeding with the research.
Rigor and trustworthiness
To ensure the quality of this qualitative study, Lincoln and Guba's (1985) criteria for trustworthiness were rigorously applied [28]. Credibility was established through member checking, where moderators summarized and verified participants' statements during interviews. In addition, to ensure coding consistency and agreement, the research team reanalyzed early interview transcripts after developing the initial codebook. Dependability was maintained by systematically documenting all research procedures, including interview guides, coding processes, and analysis notes, along with a detailed audit trail that recorded data collection steps, field notes, analysis meetings, and coding modifications. To ensure consistency across the six focus group interviews, the research team took a brief qualitative interview education and established a standardized interview guideline beforehand. Transferability was enhanced by providing thick descriptions of the research context, particularly the structural changes in Korea's healthcare system following the 2024 medical crisis, and detailed sampling criteria for the three participant groups, enabling readers to assess applicability to similar settings. Confirmability was ensured through systematic review of codes and themes during team meetings with researchers until consensus was reached, and maintenance of reflexive journals to identify researcher preconceptions. The research team's diverse clinical and academic expertise strengthened the objectivity and neutrality of the findings.
Participants’ general characteristics
A total of 44 participants were included in this study, comprising 14 novice medical support nurses, 23 experienced medical support nurses, and 7 physicians (Table 2). Among the 14 novice medical support nurses, eight were women and six were men, with a mean age of 30.3 years (SD=4.25). Their mean total clinical experience was 5.2 years (SD=4.43), with a mean of 1.2 years (SD=0.29) in the medical support service. Most were working in internal medicine (n=9), followed by surgical (n=4) and obstetrics and gynecology (n=1). Regarding recruitment, seven were assigned by their department and six applied voluntarily. Among the 23 experienced medical support nurses, 19 were women and four were men, with a mean age of 37.1 years (SD=5.54). Their mean total clinical experience was 12.8 years (SD=6.48), with a mean of 6.0 years (SD=4.21) in the medical support service. Internal medicine was the most common department (n=14), followed by surgical (n=7) and urology (n=2). Twelve applied voluntarily and eleven were assigned by their department. The seven physicians comprised three women and four men, with a mean age of 44.0 years (SD=8.29). Academic positions ranged from full-time instructor (n=1) to assistant professor (n=2), associate professor (n=3), and full-time professor (n=1). Most worked in internal medicine (n=5), with the remainder in surgical departments (n=2). In terms of experience collaborating with medical support nurses, four had less than one year, two had one to five years, and one had over ten years.
Medical support nurses’ professional identity
We found three themes and eight categories for their professional identity (Table 3): 1) Pride and Certainty of Being an Essential Professional, 2) Ambiguity and Instability due to an Ungranted Professional Position, and 3) Desire and Desperation of Specialized Professional Settlement. The results for each theme are presented below.

1. Theme 1: Pride and certainty of being an essential professional

The first theme represents the medical support nurses' positive experience from the field and their contribution to healthcare as a specialized professional. Participants recognized themselves as an essential resource in the hospital by playing a key role as specialists in specific departments.

① Pride that played a critical role in overcoming the medical crisis

All participant groups emphasized that medical support nurses play a vital role in ensuring continuity of patient care and stabilizing the workforce during disruptions in healthcare services, such as the 2024 medical crisis. Novice medical support nurses recognized their role as a communication bridge mediating the hospital system. In the absence of physicians, they ensured smooth clinical workflow by connecting departments, such as radiology, laboratory, and administrative office, through advanced medical knowledge and communication. Experienced medical support nurses expanded into a part of a physician’s scope of practice, maintaining patients’ care continuity from admission to discharge based on their expertise in nursing. The medical crisis affirmed their professional identity by enabling deep engagement in problem-solving and addressing patients’ needs. Physicians noted that the integration of medical support nurses was essential for sustaining clinical operations during the prolonged strike and resident resignations. Their primary value lies in strengthening the organization’s overall crisis response capacity and sustaining system-level resilience.
“Medical support nurse should be able to fill in the gaps when doctors not around. Also, requires advanced medical knowledge and communication skills compared to ward nurses.” (Novice Group 2, Participant 7) “Medical support nurse’s role is a bridge in the hospital…… all hospital staff such as radiologist, pathologist and administrators including nurses and doctors contact medical support nurses to schedule and coordinate work.” (Novice Group 2, Participant 2)
“A person who can deliver safe and systemic hospital experience to patients based on nurse’s expertise as well as supporting physicians to run their consultation smoothly by taking a part of their responsibility” (Experienced Group 5, Participant 3) “The most important thing is that patient treatment should not stop from admission to discharge.” (Experienced Group 1, Participant 9)
“After the medical conflict broke out last year, we failed maintaining the continuity of care to patients. Then medical support nurses were added, …… having them helped keep the care and treatment continuum……” (Physician group, Participant 2)

② Certainty as a specialized professional and a feel of reward in the field

Participants showed a common understanding that medical support nurses are both “clinical specialists” and physicians’ irreplaceable “professional partner” with knowledge and skills tailored to their specialty. They perform beyond the simple delegation by implementing their advanced clinical judgments. As specialized professionals, medical support nurses feel self-worth and fulfillment as they are recognized. Novice medical support nurses applied professional expertise at the frontline, addressed immediate clinical problems as they arose. Their abilities extend beyond supporting physicians; they assess patients, investigate issues, and make initial clinical decisions. Experienced medical support nurses consult and educate patients based on their accumulated expertise. Their specialization was highlighted as autonomous professionals whose interventions directly impact patient outcomes and long-term prognoses. They voiced a sense of fulfillment in their role. Physicians viewed medical support nurses as irreplaceable partners responsible for the entire continuum of care. They highly valued their expertise from pre-operation patient assessment and consultation, scrub nursing, and post-operative follow-up management. From their point of view, they were colleagues with a comprehensive understanding of the specific disease and field.
“When you hear the term ‘medical support nurse,’ it literally sounds like someone who just assists with medical care…… in actual practice, it goes far beyond that…… We are in a position where we take real responsibility for patient safety and the quality of care.” (Novice Group 2, Participant 4) “I’m usually the one who receives the primary call and provides the initial response…… and check on all the necessary steps. Basically, I now share some of the tasks that interns, or primary physicians used to handle in the past.” (Novice Group 2, Participant 6)
“Patients sometimes come back later for follow-up visits and tell me that they are doing well, sometimes even better than before. Hearing that makes me feel a real sense of fulfillment.” (Experienced Group 1, Participant 1)
“Medical support nurses handle the majority of tasks around surgery. They get involved from the beginning of the process when surgery is scheduled through the follow-up management in outpatient clinic.” (Physician group, Participant 4)

2. Theme 2: Ambiguity and instability due to an ungranted professional position

The second theme reveals the ambiguity and instability that medical support nurses experience due to their ungranted professional position. The ambiguity stemmed from an unclear, legally defined scope of practice, while instability was driven by frequent changes in their job title. Consequently, medical support nurses feel their position is ungranted, and they have lost respect from other healthcare professionals.

① Ambiguous scope of practice

Participants consistently described working in a ‘gray zone’ where their scope of practice is ambiguous. The legally defined scope of practice did not clearly delineate their responsibilities, tasks, and compensation. Consequently, work varied widely depending on personal capacity and interpretation, leading to concern regarding personal liability in the event of medical errors or adverse outcomes. Novice medical support nurses were unwilling to perform new clinical procedures without clear guidelines, a defined scope, and guaranteed compensation, and worried about bearing full liability in legal disputes. Experienced medical support nurses identified a structural issue caused by a discrepancy between actual clinical practices and the legally defined scope of practice. They noted that the law does not reflect their expertise, forcing many medical support nurses to operate beyond legal boundaries. Physicians pointed out dangers in the current system and criticized the ‘unspoken agreement’ where nurses work based on situational assessment rather than a formal process, calling it irresponsible and risky. However, standardizing the scope of practice is challenging, as requirements for levels of expertise vary significantly across different departments.
“If there were clear guidelines, scope of responsibility, and compensation, I would volunteer for it (intra-articular injection). But I do not want to do it if I have to take all the blame when a problem occurs.” (Novice Group 2, Participant 2)
“I believe the legal scope of practice for medical support nurses should expand. It is likely that there are many medical support nurses covering many works and responsibilities beyond what is legally permitted due to needs.” (Experienced Group 1, Participant 1)
“When defining duties, there needs to be a realistic discussion among the medical staff. ……Currently, responsibilities vary greatly depending on the individual’s capacity” (Physician group, Participant 5) “Just doing what the doctor asked for? Absolutely not. …… Medical support nurses are currently practicing based on situational assessment. I contend that nurses' have the right to demand changes.” (Physician group, Participant 7)

② Instability of a role due to change in job title

Participants recognized that medical support nurses emerged from real clinical needs; they are institutionally adrift without official status or a consistent title. This instability has confused their professional identity. Furthermore, frequent changes in job titles have limited the role’s capacity, failed to reflect their actual responsibilities, oversimplified the work, and diluted professionalism. Novice medical support nurses argued that the term “support” diminishes their role. They felt the word limits the perception of their work and fails to capture their reality as coordinators who connect the entire treatment process and facilitate the continuum of care. Experienced medical support nurses experienced title changes and a sense of lost professionalism. They had seen their position evolve from “advanced practice nurse” to “clinical practice nurse” to “medical support nurse,” which destabilized their sense of identity. The current name felt particularly problematic, appearing to shrink nursing's independent domain and position them as subordinate to physicians. Physicians saw the recent rapid increase in medical support nurses during the medical crisis, and their expansion into simpler assistant roles has lowered the professional standing of the entire group.
“I believe I play a role in connecting and coordinating the entire treatment process... but I feel trapped by the word ‘support,’ which keeps the scope of my duties narrow.” (Novice Group 2, Participant 4)
"I think that the work I'm doing is similar, but the title has changed a lot. (Experienced Group 1-Participant 9) "When I just look at the name, it's somewhat unfamiliar…… and it also seems reduced the scope of nursing, and I feel a bit like there's no independence." (Experienced Group 1-Participant 5)
“Previously, ‘advanced practice nurses’ had a certain level of clinical expertise. However, as their numbers increased …… roles simply assisting with doctors' orders, I feel that professionalism has been diluted.” (Physician group, Participant 4)

③ Loss of respect from other professionals

Participants reported experiencing a loss of respect from other healthcare professionals. Establishing a mutual understanding of the medical support nurse’s role is key to resolving their current marginalization between physicians and nurses and helping them gain empowerment and recognition as a specialized professional. Novice medical support nurses felt powerless in their relationships with ward nurses. Without official authority or a clear position in the hierarchy, they struggled to coordinate care when they encountered the established practices of senior ward nurses, making them feel like "strangers" within the nursing organization. Experienced medical support nurses felt frustrated when their role was reduced to being a messenger shuttling information back and forth. They felt used as functional tools when their professional judgment was ignored, and they simply relayed messages between doctors and departments. Physicians observed resistance from other departments when medical support nurses stepped into what used to be "doctor-to-doctor" communication, showing how the system hasn't accepted their ambiguous position.
“When I try to do something as a medical support nurse in the ward, the ward nurses say, ‘We do not usually do it this way,’ as a senior I honestly have nothing to say.” (Novice Group 2, Participant 7)
“Calling back and forth as if we are pigeons, just delivering words in the middle as powerless coordinators…… that is what is so hard.” (Experienced Group 2, Participant 3)
“Now, medical support nurses have to intervene arrangements between departments which previously made by doctor to doctor…… there are still many who feel a great resistance toward this.” (Physician group, Participant 1)

3. Theme 3: Desire and desperation of specialized professional settlement

Finally, the last theme represents participants’ perceptions of the future challenges that must be addressed for medical support nurses to be firmly settled down as specialized professionals within the system. Across groups, participants emphasized an inclination towards a solid institutional policy foundation, systemic professional education, and to grow as a sustainable, specialized professional, to achieve long-term professional integration.

① Desire for a solid institutional policy foundation

Participants expressed a strong desire for a solid institutional policy foundation regardless of their position or experience. They envisioned clearly defined and legally protected scopes of practice, essential for medical support nurses to function as legitimate professionals. They highlighted a desire for autonomy in practice and a career advancement system, underscoring the need for an institution supporting long-term professional development. Role ambiguity led to desperation for legal protection as a minimum safeguard. Novice medical support nurses preferred practical autonomy via standing orders for prompt interventions during emergencies. Experienced medical support nurses underscored a requirement for legal protection and clear role delineation to address vulnerability. Physicians emphasized that the specialized expertise of medical support nurses must be acknowledged institutionally to provide professional autonomy and sustainable career advancement. Collectively, these perspectives highlight an orientation towards formal systems that define authority and responsibility, moving beyond individual discretion or informal workplace practices.
“I wish there were medications we could use in straightforward acute situations without having to get a physician’s order every time…… If we were given prescribing authority for a standard pool of medications or standing orders, it would make our work much more efficient.” (Novice Group 1, Participant 5)
“We work in an intermediary position between physicians and nurses, and because of that, it often feels like we’re being pulled from the different directions.” (Experienced Group 2, Participant 6)
“I believe professional expertise is extremely important, but developing expertise also needs to go hand in hand with autonomy.” (Physician group, Participant 4)

② Desperation towards systemic professional education

Participants articulated desperation towards systemic professional education, as the absence of a standardized educational pathway remains a major barrier to professional development. Some reported anxiety regarding being assigned to the role without adequate preparation, noting that clinical procedures are often learned through individual effort. Participants emphasized the need for a clinically-centered standardized education system to ensure the practice quality and safe expansion of their scope. Novice medical support nurses reported that informal learning of invasive procedures caused significant anxiety and concerns regarding legal accountability when high-risk tasks are assigned without preparation. Experienced medical support nurses framed this as a threat to professional sustainability, expressing a strong inclination towards standardized education and criticizing senior-dependent training. They called for formal training pathways, including post-graduate programs and certification-based credentialing, to ensure recognition of expertise. Physicians emphasized that professional education should ensure clinical competence and academic depth, advocating for hospital-level systems, such as supervised practice hours and clinical-oriented education grounded in theoretical foundations, to support continuous learning and long-term professional development.
“I was suddenly assigned to tasks, and I had to learn how through YouTube…… I realized that I really wanted to learn everything properly, starting from the basics.” (Novice Group 1, Participant 7) “I wish there were predefined protocols and structured education that clearly outline what to do. That would make the burden much lighter.” (Novice Group 2, Participant 1)
“Rather than relying on training from senior staff, we really need professional and systematic education…… to further develop and sustain our professional expertise.”(Experienced Group 1, Participant 6) “There should be options to pursue more specialized education, such as obtaining a postgraduate degree with a specific pathway or receiving formal advanced nursing training.” (Experienced Group 2, Participant 3)
“To determine whether someone is actually qualified to perform certain tasks, there needs to be clear criteria……and that should be managed at the institutional level.” (Physician group, Participant 3) “I believe it’s essential to have a theoretical and academic foundation to become a true expert in one’s field.” (Physician group, Participant 6)

③ Aspire to grow as a sustainable specialized professional

Participants shared a common aspiration to grow as sustainable, specialized professionals, rather than temporary substitutes. They articulated a strong commitment to establish professionalism, requiring academic depth, certified qualifications, an expanded scope of practice, and fair compensation to achieve sustainable growth. Novice medical support nurses expressed a strong will to become irreplaceable professionals. They emphasized pursuing academic depth through nursing-led research and expanding their scope of practice by engaging with emerging healthcare technologies. Experienced medical support nurses underscored structural barriers, particularly the lack of fair compensation and career advancement despite advanced degrees. They called for formally recognized credentials grounded in legally defined educational standards. Physicians emphasized that routine task-based roles are unsustainable and stressed the importance of medical support nurses evolving into highly specialized professionals. They argued that the governance of specialization, credentialing, and academic development should be led by academic societies, rather than individual hospitals, to support long-term professional sustainability.
“I really like the work I’m doing right now…… I want to further develop my expertise and become an irreplaceable professional.” (Novice Group 2, Participant 6) “When residents return, our jobs may disappear…… I think it would be important to clearly establish our domain.” (Novice Group 1, Participant 2) “With systems like chatbots and telemedicine likely to expand, it would be useful to learn roles that support remote care…… connect our roles with those types of technologies.” (Novice Group 1, Participant 3)
“Even after earning degrees or certifications…… experience isn’t formally recognized, and there’s no compensation tied to those qualifications.” (Experienced Group 2, Participant 5) “To clearly define our roles, the qualifications, requirements, and educational backgrounds of dedicated medical support nurses will need to change going forward.” (Experienced Group 1, Participant 1) “There are quite a few companies now introducing AI-based monitoring tools, ……I think education and job design need to formally reflect those changes.” (Experienced Group 3, Participant 3)
“Given the rapid expansion of roles, long-term education that fosters a strong sense of ownership and professional responsibility is significant.” (Physician Group, Participant 3) “Simply performing routine tasks without specialization is not sustainable once residents return.” (Physician group, Participant 3) “The most important issue is how specialization is managed, and honestly, there are limits at the level of individual departments or hospitals……, this needs to be led at the level of academic societies.” (Physician Group, Participant 1)
The professional role identity of medical support nurses in this study was articulated through three overarching themes: “Pride and Certainty of Being an Essential Professional,” “Ambiguity and Instability Arising from an Ungranted Professional Position,” and “Desire and Desperation for the Establishment of a Specialized Professional Role.” Collectively, these themes indicate that medical support nurses perceived and experienced their role as a critical clinical function that bridges gaps in workflow within tertiary hospital settings, safeguards the continuity of care, and assumes substantial responsibility for patient safety. Importantly, these proactive and positive roles were enacted amid persistent ambiguity and instability stemming from insufficient legal recognition and underdeveloped institutional frameworks, thereby constraining the stable construction of professional identity.
The theme “Pride and Certainty of Being an Essential Professional” reflected participants’ recognition of their role in sustaining clinical workflow and continuity of care in tertiary hospital settings. Beyond performing “support tasks,” medical support nurses were described as bridging departments, coordinating care across the treatment continuum, and providing initial responses in urgent situations. The significance of medical support nurses’ role became especially salient during the 2024 medical crisis in Korea, where resident resignations and resulting disruptions in healthcare services created critical gaps in clinical workflow. In this context, the role of the medical support nurse was specifically described as filling the gap “when doctors are not around,” “requiring advanced medical knowledge and communication skills compared to ward nurses,” and “functioning as a bridge in the hospital.” Consequently, continuity of care emerged as a core professional value—ensuring that “patient treatment should not stop”—while their certainty as specialized professionals was reinforced through a direct linkage to taking “real responsibility for patient safety and the quality of care.” In Korea, informal medical support roles had existed in tertiary hospitals well before the 2024 medical crisis, as reflected by the mean role experience of 6.0 years among experienced participants. The crisis accelerated the formal recognition of a workforce that had long been embedded in clinical practice, yet remained without institutional legitimacy. This finding helps explain why participants perceived themselves as essential professionals while simultaneously experiencing uncertainty regarding their professional position.
The theme “Ambiguity and Instability due to an Ungranted Professional Position” derived from the interviews reflected a persistent gray zone created by insufficient institutional recognition and unclear legal frameworks [25,29]. The scope of practice, responsibility, and compensation were not clearly delineated. Therefore, legal accountability may remain a constant concern, and role execution may depend on individual competencies rather than standardized protocols [15,30]. This tension could contribute to hesitation to expand practice, particularly when the fear of “taking all the blame” arises in the absence of clear guidelines. Such hesitation may be further intensified by job title changes that fail to reflect actual competence; the term “support” may be perceived as trapping them in duties that are too narrow. Furthermore, these conditions could negatively affect interprofessional interactions, where limited mutual understanding often results in them being positioned as “powerless coordinators.” Studies from other countries have also highlighted these challenges, identifying similar issues regarding role ambiguity, inconsistent regulation, and boundary tensions between physicians and nurses [24,31-34]. Given the evidence linking such environments to job dissatisfaction [35] and potential risks to patient safety [36], this theme underscores the urgent need for institutional positioning that aligns with their advanced expertise [10].
The theme “Desire and Desperation of Specialized Professional Settlement” derived from the interviews captured a strong orientation toward long-term professional integration rather than temporary substitution. First, regarding the desire for a solid institutional policy foundation, legal protection was positioned as a minimum safeguard, particularly where ambiguity constrains autonomy [30]. Medical support nurses specifically requested standing orders to ensure practical autonomy and efficiency. Second, the desperation towards systemic professional education was emphasized as essential for safe practice. Medical support nurses described reliance on informal resources such as YouTube as a source of anxiety, reinforcing a desire for “structured education.” Third, nurses expressed a desperation to grow as sustainable specialized professionals by linking career sustainability to certified qualifications and fair compensation, despite persistent concerns that there is “no compensation” tied to advanced roles. These findings aligned with international evidence emphasizing that legislated scopes of practice and legal protection are foundational for stable role development [10,37]. Furthermore, some studies demonstrated that structured education, regulation, and clear career pathways are critical determinants of recruitment and retention [33,38].
The implication of this study is that achieving professional settlement for medical support nurses may require a multilayered and integrated approach that extends beyond temporary policy responses or reliance on individual competence [10,39]. While individual competence constitute an important foundation of professional practice, professionalism is sustained through institutional and systemic support that standardized practice, ensure accountability and facilitate continuous competency development [40]. When professional roles depend solely on personal capacity within ambiguous structures, professional identity may remain vulnerable, and practice may continue to operate in a gray zone [35]. Consequently, institutionalization is needed across three interconnected areas—legal–institutional frameworks, systemic professional education, and career development pathways—to transition these nurses from a state of contingency and ambiguity toward legitimacy, sustainability, and professional autonomy [35].
Specifically, institutional frameworks should be established as follows. First, legal–institutional frameworks should establish clear definitions and standards for clinical practice. Clear delineation of scope of practice, responsibility, and compensation, may reduce variability in role performance, enhance accountability and provide the organizational foundation necessary for professional recognition and position of medical support nurses [10,39]. Furthermore, the institutionalization of medical support nurses should be considered within an interprofessional practice context. In this study, medical support nurses constructed their professional identity through bridging roles among physicians, nurses, departments, and patients; however, this position also exposed them to unclear role boundaries and unstable recognition within physician-led clinical systems. Similar interprofessional tensions have been identified as barriers to role legitimacy in other countries [37-41]. Therefore, role settlement may benefit from interprofessional collaboration systems, including clearly defined role agreements, shared protocols, and formalized communication channels among physicians, nurses, and administrators. Such systems may facilitate mutual understanding of roles and responsibilities and support the stable integration of medical support nurses within healthcare teams.
Second, systemic professional education should replace informal learning methods to support the development of a sustainable educational pathway. Educational pathways should integrate strong theoretical foundations with rigorously regulated clinical training, supported by graduate-level programs and academic–clinical partnerships to ensure practice quality and patient safety [41,42]. In addition, educational pathways should prepare medical support nurses for emerging healthcare environments characterized by interprofessional collaboration and increasing integration of digital technologies. Future educational pathways should incorporate interprofessional education competencies and foundational artificial intelligence (AI) literacy. Given that medical support nurses perform coordination-intensive roles in complex tertiary hospital systems, curricula may need to address team-based communication, role negotiation, and the responsible use of digital and AI-supported clinical information. The American Association of Colleges of Nursing (AACN) Essentials emphasize interprofessional partnerships and informatics-related competencies as core components of contemporary nursing education, while nursing AI literature highlights the need for nurses to actively engage with AI development and implementation in healthcare systems [43,44]. As AI becomes increasingly embedded in clinical practice, medical support nurses may need basic competencies to interpret AI-generated information, recognize its limitations, and maintain professional accountability in algorithm-informed care environments [43]. AI should therefore be positioned as a supportive tool for standardized practice and clinical coordination, rather than as a substitute for professional judgment.
Third, career development pathways should be designed to support long-term professional development through formal recognition of accumulated expertise. Structured certification-based advancement systems, including tiered roles and specialty career tracks linked to fair compensation, may promote long-term professional growth [10,38,39]. Collectively, these approaches may support the transition of medical support nurses toward greater legitimacy through clearer role accountability, sustainability through strengthened interprofessional collaboration and recognition in tertiary hospital settings.
Another implication of this study concerns the critical gap between the advanced roles actually performed in Korean tertiary hospitals and the underdeveloped institutional foundations [32]. Although Korean medical support nurses perform functions comparable to those in the United States, the United Kingdom, Canada, and Australia, practice in Korea have continued to operate without the defined scopes of practice and standardized education established in those nations [10,45,46]. While this disparity may reflect a historically hierarchical healthcare system and persistent interprofessional tensions [29], the changing global context—characterized by physician shortages and disruptions in healthcare delivery—may suggest that advanced practice nursing personnel increasingly indispensable across healthcare systems [47]. Therefore, to ensure patient safety and workforce stability, policy efforts should move beyond temporal responses. Instead, establishing durable legal frameworks and systematic education could be essential to support a legitimate and sustainable workforce in tertiary hospital settings [10,39].
Beyond the Korean context, the experiences identified in this study may reflect broader international challenges associated with integrating medical support services and the nursing personnel who perform these roles within contemporary healthcare systems [47,48]. To sustain healthcare service delivery and improve access to care, many countries have expanded advanced nursing and medical support roles through healthcare workforce redesign and task redistribution strategies [47,49,50]. However, international literature continues to report persistent challenges related to role ambiguity, regulatory inconsistency, unclear professional boundaries, and limited institutional recognition [34,51]. Therefore, the professional identity issues identified in this study may not be unique to Korea but rather represent a broader global healthcare workforce challenge arising from the ongoing redistribution of clinical responsibilities and roles within interprofessional healthcare teams.
This study made distinct contributions to the professional identity of medical support nurses. First, separate focus group interviews with novice and experienced nurses minimized hierarchical constraints and supported deeper discussion. Second, inclusion of collaborating physicians allowed direct examination of interprofessional perceptions and showed that medical support nurses were viewed as professional partners [31,52]. Third, attention to the context of the 2024 medical crisis highlighted structural vulnerability despite an essential role in maintaining continuity of care [53]. Finally, methodological rigor was strengthened through the application of Graneheim and Lundman’s content analysis framework [27].
Several limitations should be considered when interpreting these findings. First, as the study was conducted in a single tertiary referral hospital, transferability to other healthcare settings may be limited. Future studies should include diverse institutional contexts to enhance external validity. Second, physicians were self-selected, which may have introduced selection bias, as they may have held more favorable views toward medical support nurses or interprofessional collaboration. Third, the cross-sectional design precluded examination of changes in professional identity over time; longitudinal research is therefore needed to capture its dynamic development across career stages. Fourth, this study did not examine whether medical support nurses held advanced practice nurse certification which may have influenced professional role identity [54]. Future research should investigate potential differences in professional identity according to advanced practice nurse certification status. Finally, although this study included medical support nurses and collaborating physicians, future research should incorporate additional stakeholders, such as nurse managers, administrators, and policymakers, to provide a more comprehensive understanding of the organizational and policy contexts shaping professional identity and specialized professional settlement.
This qualitative study identified key themes of the professional role identity of medical support nurses within the highly specialized context of a tertiary referral hospital, drawing on perspectives from nurses across career stages as well as physicians as their primary collaborative partners. These themes elucidate both the roles currently enacted by medical support nurses and the conditions necessary for their future professional consolidation. In particular, the findings indicate that insufficient institutionalization and an ambiguous scope of practice may constrain the establishment of a stable professional identity. Accordingly, the study underscores the need for institutionalization to strengthen professional role identity and ensure the long-term sustainability of medical support nurses, including legal definition, standards for clinical practice, standardized education, and structured career development pathways. Collectively, these findings provide empirical evidence to inform future policy development and institutionalization efforts within the Korean healthcare system.

Conflict of interest

The authors declared no conflict of interest.

Funding

This research was supported by the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) grant from the Ministry of Science and ICT, Korean Government (No. RS-2024-00336847), and by a grant from the Korea University Nursing Research Institute.

Authors’ contributions

Jina Choo contributed to conceptualization, funding acquisition, supervision, writing-review & editing, methodology, and project administration. Suejin Kim contributed to writing-original draft, investigation, and formal analysis. Yura Shin contributed to formal analysis, writing-review & editing, data curation, and validation. Songwhi Noh contributed to formal analysis, writing-review & editing, data curation, and validation. Jiye Min contributed to formal analysis, writing-review & editing, data curation, and validation.

Youngsoo Chu contributed to writing-review & editing. Mi Yu contributed to writing-review & editing. Soonhee Yoon contributed to writing-review & editing. Sung Reul Kim contributed to writing-review & editing. Yura Choi contributed to investigation, resources, and writing-review & editing. Eunyeong Park contributed to investigation, resources, and writing-review & editing. Gyuhee Han contributed to investigation, resources, and writing-review & editing. Eunsil Jeong contributed to investigation, resources, and writing-review & editing. Soohyun Ryu contributed to investigation, resources, and writing-review & editing.

Gyeongeun Choi contributed to writing-review & editing.

Data availability

Data is available upon reasonable request. The data set used is available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.

Acknowledgements

There is currently no internationally established English terminology for nurses performing medical support practice within the Korean healthcare system. Accordingly, the term “medical support nurses” was used throughout this manuscript. This terminology was derived from the official English translation of medical support services provided by the Korean Law Information Center and is intended to reflect the Korean legal and policy context. The term is used for the purposes of this study and should not be interpreted as representing an internationally standardized designation.

Table 1.
Focus Groups and Their Number of Participants
No. Focus group Number of participants
1 Novice group 1 7
2 Novice group 2 7
3 Experienced group 1 9
4 Experienced group 2 7
5 Experienced group 3 7
6 Physician group 7
Table 2.
Participants’ General Characteristics
Position Characteristics Categories n Mean (SD†)
Novice medical support nurse (n=14) Age (year) 30.3 (4.25)
Gender Woman 8
Man 6
Total clinical experience (years) 5.2 (4.43)
Experience as a medical support nurse (years) 1.2 (0.29)
Current department Surgical 4
Internal medicine 9
Obstetrics & Gynecology 1
Urology 0
Recruitment path Voluntary application 6
Department assignment 8
Experienced medical support nurse (n=23) Age (year) 37.1 (5.54)
Gender Woman 19
Man 4
Total clinical experience (years) 12.8 (6.48)
Experience as a medical support nurse (years) 6.0 (4.21)
Current department Surgical 7
Internal medicine 14
Obstetrics & Gynecology 0
Urology 2
Recruitment path Voluntary application 12
Department assignment 11
Physicians (n=7) Age (year) 44.0 (8.29)
Gender Woman 3
Man 4
Full-time instructor 1
Assistant professor 2
Associate professor 3
Full-time professor 1
Current department Surgical 2
Internal medicine 5
Obstetrics & Gynecology 0
Urology 0
Experience working with medical support nurses <1 year 4
1-<5 years 2
5-<10 years 0
≥10 years 1

†SD=standard deviation.

Table 3.
Medical Support Nurses’ Professional Identity
Themes Categories Sub-categories
Pride and Certainty of Being an Essential Professional Pride that played a critical role in overcoming the medical crisis • Pride in protecting continuity of care of patients
• Perceived presence as the one who overcome healthcare gap
• Sense of accomplishment mediating the whole system
Certainty as a specialized professional and a feel of reward in the field • Self-worth as a specialized professional
• Fulfillment as a patient care professional
• Joy of being recognized as a specialized professional
Ambiguity and Instability due to an Ungranted Professional Position Ambiguous scope of practice • Unclear responsibility, scope, and compensation of role
• Varies in practice by an individual's capacity due to ambiguous job description defined by law
Instability of a role due to change in job title • Feels position name limits the capacity
• Position name does not represent the responsibility of the role
• Diluted professionalism due to simplified role name and task
Loss of respect from other professionals • Lack of mutual understanding regarding to the position
• Loss of respect and empowerment as a specialized professional
Desire and Desperation of Specialized Professional Settlement Desire for a solid institutional policy foundation • Desire for the autonomy in practice
• Desperation in legal protection
• Expectation for career advancement system
Desperation towards systemic professional education • Anxiety about being deployed without preparation
• Inclination for the standardized education system
• Wishing for clinical-centered education
Aspire to grow as a sustainable specialized professional • Desire to pursue academical depth
• Will to establish professionalism
• Expectation around a certified qualification
• Aspiration on expanding the scope of practice
• Desire for fair compensation

Figure & Data

References

    Citations

    Citations to this article as recorded by  

      We recommend
      Professional Role Identity of Medical Support Nurses in Tertiary Hospitals: A Qualitative Content Analysis
      Professional Role Identity of Medical Support Nurses in Tertiary Hospitals: A Qualitative Content Analysis
      No. Focus group Number of participants
      1 Novice group 1 7
      2 Novice group 2 7
      3 Experienced group 1 9
      4 Experienced group 2 7
      5 Experienced group 3 7
      6 Physician group 7
      Position Characteristics Categories n Mean (SD†)
      Novice medical support nurse (n=14) Age (year) 30.3 (4.25)
      Gender Woman 8
      Man 6
      Total clinical experience (years) 5.2 (4.43)
      Experience as a medical support nurse (years) 1.2 (0.29)
      Current department Surgical 4
      Internal medicine 9
      Obstetrics & Gynecology 1
      Urology 0
      Recruitment path Voluntary application 6
      Department assignment 8
      Experienced medical support nurse (n=23) Age (year) 37.1 (5.54)
      Gender Woman 19
      Man 4
      Total clinical experience (years) 12.8 (6.48)
      Experience as a medical support nurse (years) 6.0 (4.21)
      Current department Surgical 7
      Internal medicine 14
      Obstetrics & Gynecology 0
      Urology 2
      Recruitment path Voluntary application 12
      Department assignment 11
      Physicians (n=7) Age (year) 44.0 (8.29)
      Gender Woman 3
      Man 4
      Full-time instructor 1
      Assistant professor 2
      Associate professor 3
      Full-time professor 1
      Current department Surgical 2
      Internal medicine 5
      Obstetrics & Gynecology 0
      Urology 0
      Experience working with medical support nurses <1 year 4
      1-<5 years 2
      5-<10 years 0
      ≥10 years 1
      Themes Categories Sub-categories
      Pride and Certainty of Being an Essential Professional Pride that played a critical role in overcoming the medical crisis • Pride in protecting continuity of care of patients
      • Perceived presence as the one who overcome healthcare gap
      • Sense of accomplishment mediating the whole system
      Certainty as a specialized professional and a feel of reward in the field • Self-worth as a specialized professional
      • Fulfillment as a patient care professional
      • Joy of being recognized as a specialized professional
      Ambiguity and Instability due to an Ungranted Professional Position Ambiguous scope of practice • Unclear responsibility, scope, and compensation of role
      • Varies in practice by an individual's capacity due to ambiguous job description defined by law
      Instability of a role due to change in job title • Feels position name limits the capacity
      • Position name does not represent the responsibility of the role
      • Diluted professionalism due to simplified role name and task
      Loss of respect from other professionals • Lack of mutual understanding regarding to the position
      • Loss of respect and empowerment as a specialized professional
      Desire and Desperation of Specialized Professional Settlement Desire for a solid institutional policy foundation • Desire for the autonomy in practice
      • Desperation in legal protection
      • Expectation for career advancement system
      Desperation towards systemic professional education • Anxiety about being deployed without preparation
      • Inclination for the standardized education system
      • Wishing for clinical-centered education
      Aspire to grow as a sustainable specialized professional • Desire to pursue academical depth
      • Will to establish professionalism
      • Expectation around a certified qualification
      • Aspiration on expanding the scope of practice
      • Desire for fair compensation
      Table 1. Focus Groups and Their Number of Participants

      Table 2. Participants’ General Characteristics

      SD=standard deviation.

      Table 3. Medical Support Nurses’ Professional Identity


      RCPHN : Research in Community and Public Health Nursing
      TOP